top of page

Why Didn’t You Leave Sooner?

Jul 20, 2025
4 min read

Challenging the Narrative, Honoring the Journey


There is a question that lingers in the air like smoke after a fire, one that survivors of domestic violence often face not just from strangers or courtrooms, but from people we expected to understand: “Why didn’t you leave sooner?”


It’s not just the words that sting—it’s the implication that our pain was somehow elective, that we chose to stay where we weren’t safe, that if the abuse was “that bad,” we would’ve walked out the door.


The truth is, that door is not always visible when you’re inside the house, especially when the house is filled with gaslighting, fear, control, and hope that things might finally change. That question doesn’t just minimize our trauma. It reflects a fundamental societal misunderstanding of how abuse works, how trauma bonds are formed, and how victims are conditioned over time to see escape as either impossible or pointless, or more harmful than staying.


What hurts me most is how often that question has come from other women. And I say that not in anger, but in grief. Because if we’re ever going to dismantle the cycles of harm, we need to start by supporting each other.


Women need to stop asking why she stayed, and start asking, how can I help her feel safe now?

I’ve been in more than one abusive relationship, but the final one taught me something I’ll never forget. We had already broken up. I had begged him to move out. I tried everything to keep the peace while getting him out of our small two bedroom home. The walls were thin, sounds and memories echoed off them like a misdirected game of pool. One day, in yet another exhausting, circular conversation, I asked, “If you figure something out, will you let me know?” My tone was calm and even. My feelings: desperate. Afterall, the eggshells I'd been walking on were long worn down years ago.


The neighbors went silent for an instant. The cars on the highway stopped moving. The breeze on the prairie across the lake settled. His eyes fixed on me. Not like he was looking at me—he was looking through me. Like I was transparent. Like I didn’t exist beyond the game we played when we met eachother. I never existed to begin with. He erased me. There was a smirk—not joyful, not even smug—but hollow. It was the face of someone who felt full from watching me squirm. "I don't think I will."


But while my memory had never seen that look before, my body remembered it. So I played along. And I was so cool. I just smiled flatly back and replied, "Ok," and walked out of the room, effectively ending the interaction.

How did I know how to respond like that? That's a different part of my story.


Survivors of malignant narcissists have described that look. I didn’t imagine it.


And on the day he finally left (not more than seven days later), I tested what my nervous system had always suspected with him. I leaned in for a goodbye hug, still desperate for some version of closure, some softness to prove I hadn’t hallucinated everything. But his arms—his whole body—were stiff, skeletal. This isn't a description of his body. It is a description of the hug. It just wasn’t a hug. It was a leaning post. There was no warmth. No care. No grief. No recognition. And that absence of emotion—it wasn't just in that moment. It had been the entire relationship. I just refused to acknoledge it.


He hugged me that way on the day he met me for the first time at the airport. And I had been chasing the warmth, the emotion, the response, the... anything. Because trauma convinces you that if you can just be lovable enough, safe enough, easy enough, small enough, quiet enough, digestable enough- you can turn a monster into the person you thought they were at the beginning.


I had to read my way out of that trap.


Whitney Cummings’s book, I'm Fine... and Other Lies, gave me permission to name my patterns. I found Trauma Bonding by Lauren Kozlowski before I even knew narcissism as a behavior pattern, much less a diagnosis. All I knew was something felt very wrong, and I wanted to heal. I kept asking myself,

  • Why does he describe our relationship as so great, when I feel like I’m unraveling?

  • Was I the problem?

  • Was I depressed?

  • Was I imagining things?


Then I read Gaslighting by Olivia Parent. Then Narcissistic Relationship Recovery, Kozlowski’s second book. Then I found Dr. Ramani Durvasula’s YouTube channel.


And it all clicked. I wasn’t crazy. I wasn’t overreacting. I was in a cycle that had trained me to doubt my own eyes, voice, and worth. I had to rebuild trust with myself from the ground up. I had to heal the parts of me that lead me to him in the first place, the parts of me that felt safe abandoning myself for his comfort, the parts of me I completely left along the way.


So if you’re reading this as a survivor still stuck in the shame of your timeline, please hear this:

You didn’t stay because you were weak. You stayed because you were surviving. You stayed because you were hoping. You stayed because you were trying to protect yourself.

And if you’re someone who supports survivors, consider what it does when we question their timelines instead of honoring their strength. Let’s do better. Let’s listen without judgment. Let’s stand beside the ones who are still figuring it out.

If this resonated with you, please share your thoughts in the comments. Survivors heal in community. Your words might be the rope someone else needs.

Resources for Support:

 
 
 

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page